Local Faves to Perfect Your Thanksgiving Table
Thanksgiving is all about indulgence, tradition, and a table filled with flavors that hit every nostalgic note. But it’s also the perfect excuse to explore the NYC suburbs and snag some next-level treats for your holiday spread. As you visit towns and scope out potential new neighborhoods, why not bring home a little slice (or several) of what makes these communities so special? From iconic bakeries to hidden gems, these spots will elevate your Thanksgiving table—and give you a true taste of suburban charm.
Westchester County
Galloway’s Bakery – Scarsdale
69 Harney Road, Scarsdale; 914.725.4074
Westchester natives know Galloway’s is the place for pies. Whether you’re into classic apple, pecan, or towering meringue, this family-run favorite delivers every time. The secret? Decades of tradition baked into every flaky crust. Pro tip: lines are long on Thanksgiving Eve, but they move fast—and trust us, it’s worth the wait.
Noble Pies – Rye & Tarrytown
22 Purdy Avenue, Rye; 914.305.3174
38 Main St, Tarrytown; 914.418.5649
This isn’t just pie. It’s an experience. Noble Pies prides itself on scratch-made, award-winning creations like pumpkin, cherry, and chocolate cream. Pop into either location, pre-order your faves, and maybe grab an extra “just for now” slice. After all, research tastes better with pie.
Red Barn Bakery – Irvington
4 S Astor Street, Irvington; 914.231.7779
Red Barn’s artisanal, organic pies scream “Thanksgiving showstopper.” Think salted caramel apple, pumpkin chiffon, and ginger peach with vegan and gluten-free options that don’t skimp on flavor—a must-stop for anyone who wants their dessert to double as a conversation piece.
Seth Greenberg’s Just Desserts – Larchmont
1887 Palmer Avenue, Larchmont; 914.630.1807
Thanksgiving dessert, but make it decadent. Greenberg’s signature pumpkin pie cheesecake and overstuffed apple crumb pie deliver a serious “wow” factor. Not in the mood to share? We wouldn’t blame you.
Fairfield County
The Pantry – Fairfield
1580 Post Road, Fairfield; 203.259.0400
The Pantry elevates Thanksgiving staples to gourmet status. Their cranberry walnut pie has a cult following, and their buttery, flaky crusts are guaranteed to outshine even your favorite aunt’s recipe.
Kneads Bakery – Westport
580 Riverside Avenue, Westport; 203.349.5341
Part bakery, part art gallery, Kneads crafts pies so stunning they deserve their centerpiece. Flavors range from traditional to creative, with each bite showcasing the kind of care only a true pie artist could deliver.
Michele’s Pies – Norwalk
666 Main Avenue, Norwalk; 203.354.7144
Award-winning and unforgettable, Michele’s cranberry apple and chocolate pecan pies are the stuff of legends. This is the place to go if you want your Thanksgiving dessert to earn a standing ovation.
Northern New Jersey
Ladyfingers Bakery & Bar – Bloomfield
1109 Broad Street, Bloomfield; 973.343.5110
Thanksgiving, but make it chic? Check out this Bloomfield staple. Ladyfingers pair posh desserts with a side of boozy flair. Dutch apple, chocolate pudding, and pecan pies arrive in sleek pink boxes that scream sophistication. Why not pick up a cheesecake pop or two for the road?
The Able Baker – Maplewood
187 Maplewood Avenue, Maplewood; 973.313.1133
Local legend meets innovative flavor at The Able Baker. Their Salted Maple Pie is a standout, but don’t sleep on classics like pumpkin and pecan. Bonus: their flourless chocolate soufflé cake (in pie form!) is perfect for the chocoholics in your family.
Sook Pastry – Ridgewood
24 S Broad Street, Ridgewood; 201.493.2500
Searching for a slice of Paris in New Jersey? From bourbon pecan to pumpkin spice, Sook’s pies bring French elegance to your Thanksgiving table. Pair with one of their croissants for the ultimate next-day breakfast.
Jayce Baudry French Pastry – Montclair
17 Church Street, Montclair; 973.531.6464
Sophisticated and stunning, Jayce Baudry elevates pie-making to an art form–no surprise, considering Baudry comes from one of NYC’s finest, Daniel. Their chocolate bourbon pecan and apple crumb pies are almost too pretty to eat—but trust us, you’ll manage.
Nassau County, Long Island
Youngs Farm – Old Brookville
91 Hegemans Lane, Old Brookville; 516.671.3117
Locals know that Youngs Farm pies are non-negotiable at Thanksgiving. The pumpkin pie is the classic choice, but their apple crumb and cherry pies are equally divine. While you’re there, pick up some fresh produce for the rest of your feast.
The French Workshop – Garden City
191 7th Street, Garden City; 516.888.7611
The French Workshop’s patissiers turn out stunning creations like pumpkin, pecan, and cherry pies that taste as good as they look. Don’t leave without sampling their macarons. A Thanksgiving classic? Not exactly. But one bite, and it’s clear why these sweets deserve a spot on your table.
Polka Dot Pound Cake – Rockville Centre
217 N Long Beach Road, Rockville Centre; 516.208.2410
For a pie with flair, Polka Dot’s cranberry apple pie is a standout. It blends cinnamon, orange zest, and the perfect crumbly topping. It’s a slice of Thanksgiving with a modern twist.
Why Stop at Dessert?
Exploring these towns is about more than just the perfect pie (though, let’s be real, pie is a major motivator). It’s a chance to connect with the community, experience local charm, and imagine what life could be like in your future hometown.
Pick up a pie, linger over coffee, and stroll through town. Chat with locals, explore the parks, and soak up the vibe. Because these places aren’t just where you buy dessert—they’re where you might find your next chapter.
So, as you map out your suburban search, don’t forget to bring home a taste of what could be. After all, dessert makes everything better—even big decisions.
For more insights, visit SJ’s New York City suburbs section and the New York City blog page on our website. Ready to explore the suburban sweets scene (and more)?
Let’s talk! Schedule a free initial strategy call today.
