When it comes to moving out of the city, some people want a bustling suburban hub with multiple neighborhoods, big shopping centers, and a little bit of everything. Others? They’re craving something more quiet and intimate – the kind of town where everyone knows your name, you have a go-to coffee shop, and your kids grow up playing with the same crew from kindergarten to high school.
At Suburban Jungle, our Strategists spend a lot of time helping families navigate this balance. One key element? The size and feel of the community. If you’re leaning toward the smaller-town side of the suburban scale, Westchester is packed with picture-perfect villages that check every box. Many even come with highly-ranked school districts, strong community ties, and just the right dose of charm.
Here are a few of our favorite small-town suburbs just outside of NYC:
Bronxville
Why we love it: Walkability, top-tier schools, and a charming village vibe just 30 minutes from Manhattan.
This one-square-mile Westchester gem is often one of the first small towns we talk about with city families—and for good reason. Bronxville combines a classic, tight-knit community feel with one of the shortest commutes to Manhattan you’ll find. The district is nationally ranked, with schools located on the same campus—ideal for streamlined pick-up and drop-off.
The downtown is walkable and picturesque, with upscale boutiques, restaurants, a beloved bookshop, and a strong sense of community. From coffee runs to kids’ soccer games, you’ll get to know your neighbors fast.
Vibe: Classic village charm with a cosmopolitan edge
Bonus: A+ academics and strong sports programs
Rye Brook
Rye Brook is small but mighty. This tight-knit village has beautiful neighborhoods, a highly-ranked school district, and lots of green space. The Rye Ridge Shopping Center covers your daily needs with grocery stores, fitness studios, restaurants, and more.
Why we love it: A cozy village feel, great schools, and access to big amenities in neighboring towns.
Even better, you’re situated between Rye and Greenwich, CT, two towns known for their shopping, dining, and cultural events. It’s a win-win: small-town living with big-town perks just a few minutes away.
Vibe: Quiet and community-oriented, with access to everything nearby
Bonus: Convenient location and a wide range of home styles
Briarcliff Manor
Why we love it: Scenic beauty, outdoor space, and that true tucked-away village charm.
Briarcliff Manor is one of those under-the-radar Hudson River towns that wins people over with its nature, peace, and panoramic views. There’s a charming main street, but much of the town is residential—and surrounded by trees, trails, and parks.
What sets Briarcliff apart? Its amazing municipal community center, which includes fields, a pool, and tons of rec programming for families. The schools are excellent, and the community is very active.
Vibe: Peaceful, private, and nature-forward
Bonus: Hudson River views and a fantastic community center
Edgemont (Greenville)
Why we love it: A hidden gem for those seeking privacy, beautiful homes, and proximity to Scarsdale.
Edgemont is a unique Westchester spot known for its large, private properties and exceptional schools. It doesn’t have a traditional village center, but what it lacks in walkability it makes up for in serenity, elegance, and location. You’re right next to Scarsdale, so you can easily access its amenities—think Metro North, restaurants, shopping, and more—without giving up that tucked-away residential feel.
This is a great choice for families looking for a quieter, more private setting with a highly-regarded school system and easy access to Manhattan.
Vibe: Elegant, peaceful, and private
Bonus: Access to Scarsdale perks without the Scarsdale price tag
Small Town, Big Lifestyle
If you’re dreaming of a smaller suburb—where the barista knows your name and your kids walk to school with their best friends—these towns should be at the top of your list. Each offers a unique balance of charm, community, and access—plus the support systems, schools, and lifestyle amenities that make for an incredible day-to-day experience.
Ready to find your perfect small-town suburb? Schedule your free initial strategy call today and let’s explore the best small-town options for your next big move.
